Pin it
Last winter, my kitchen turned into a Christmas paradise when I whipped up these Gingerbread Cheesecake Cookies. There's something magical about that mix of soft, spicy gingerbread wrapped around a silky cheesecake center. I first tried these after my pumpkin cheesecake cookies were such a smash hit. Now everyone begs for them when the holidays roll around.
Why These Treats Stand Out
I've come to think of these cookies as my holiday calling card. They've got the most amazing texture - soft and chewy outside with that unexpected creamy surprise inside. The warm spices mixed with rich molasses taste just like Christmas in cookie form. My buddy Sarah swears they beat anything she's ever bought at fancy bakeries, and that always makes me smile.
Your Ingredient List
- Butter: Leave it out to soften on the counter for easier mixing.
- Brown sugar: This gives you that wonderful chewy bite.
- Dark molasses: The key to authentic gingerbread flavor.
- Fresh egg yolks: Make sure they're at room temp for best results.
- Pure vanilla: I like to use vanilla bean paste, but regular extract works great too.
- Basic flour: Take time to measure it right for consistent results.
- Leavening: A bit of baking soda helps them puff up nicely.
- Salt: This wakes up all those wonderful spice flavors.
- Warm spices: My custom mix includes ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, and cloves.
- White sugar: For both the filling and the spiced coating.
- Cream cheese: The hero of our dreamy centers.
Creating Your Cookie Wonders
- Begin With The Centers
- I mix cream cheese, sugar and vanilla until smooth and airy. Then I scoop tiny portions and stick them in the freezer. This trick guarantees perfect centers every time.
- The Cookie Dough
- While the centers get firm, I combine my spiced flour mix. Then I beat butter with brown sugar until fluffy. After that, I add molasses, egg yolks and vanilla, mixing until everything looks rich and lovely.
- Putting It All Together
- Here comes the best part. Grab some cookie dough, press it flat, add a frozen cheesecake center, and fold the dough around it like wrapping a tiny gift. Then roll in spiced sugar for extra sparkle.
- Baking Time
- I only bake six cookies per batch for the best outcome. They need about 10 minutes before carefully moving them to cool completely.
Pin it
Questions You Might Have
My cookies used to turn out too cakey until I started using a kitchen scale for my flour. It changed everything. Don't worry if they look puffy when they first come out of the oven. They'll flatten as they cool. They'll stay fresh in containers for three days, though at my house they're usually gone way before then.
Tricks I've Learned
After baking these countless times, I've picked up some handy tips. Getting your flour measurement right makes all the difference - either weigh it or use the spoon and level method. Keep those cheesecake centers frozen solid until you're ready to use them. Let the cookies cool all the way so the filling sets up right. My favorite hack is using a big round cookie cutter to shape hot cookies into perfect circles.
Keeping Them Fresh
These cookies need a bit of extra care. Pop them in any airtight container and they'll taste great for about three days. I often make a double batch and freeze some for unexpected company. They can last two weeks in the freezer, though we usually can't resist them that long. My daughter always gets excited when she finds them tucked away for an after-school snack.
Wonderful For Gifting
I've started giving these cookies as holiday presents. Last Christmas I put them in cute boxes with colorful tissue paper for my kids' teachers and our neighbors. Watching people's reactions when they discover that creamy center makes all the work worthwhile. My book club now expects them at our December gatherings.
Creating Traditions
The real joy of these cookies isn't just how good they taste. It's about the fun we have making them. My house fills with spicy gingerbread smells while the kids help roll dough balls in sugar. We end up with flour everywhere, but those laughs and sticky fingers are worth every bit of cleanup. These treats have become a must-have part of our family Christmas traditions.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why freeze the cheesecake filling?
- Freezing helps the filling get firm enough to work with and wrap in cookie dough. It also stops it from melting too fast while baking.
- → Can I make these ahead?
- You can freeze the filling beforehand and prep the cookie dough a day early. Just put them together and bake when you're ready.
- → Why bake only 6 at a time?
- This makes sure they all cook the same and gives enough room for slight spreading. It also keeps your unused dough nice and cool.
- → How do I store these cookies?
- Keep them in a sealed container in your fridge for up to 5 days because of the cream cheese center.
- → Why use unsulphured molasses?
- Unsulphured molasses tastes lighter and smoother than blackstrap molasses, which would make your cookies too intense and bitter.