Pin it
I totally fell for this crockpot mac and cheese the first time I whipped it up for my family get-together. There's something magical about how the cheese turns into this amazing sauce that hugs every pasta piece. Since trying this, I've tossed all my boxed mac and cheese. Now it's my favorite comfort dish for family dinners, get-togethers, or just when we want something warm and satisfying.
Effortless Comfort Done Right
The best part? My slow cooker handles everything while I take care of other stuff. The sauce comes out super creamy without fail, coating each noodle perfectly. I sometimes play around with different cheese types or add-ons, but I always come back to the basic version because it just works so well.
Your Ingredients List
- Cooking spray: A little spray now saves you tons of scrubbing later.
- 1 pound elbow macaroni: These little curved tubes grab all that yummy sauce.
- 2 cans evaporated milk: This makes our sauce incredibly smooth and velvety.
- 2 cups whole milk: Helps everything blend together wonderfully.
- 1 stick butter: Let's face it, good mac and cheese needs the real stuff.
- 4 cups sharp cheddar: Grab a block and grate it yourself, you'll taste the difference.
- Salt and pepper: Add to match your own taste buds.
- Paprika: A dash on top gives it a pretty pop of color.
Easy Cooking Method
- Get Your Crockpot Ready
- First, give your crockpot a good spray with cooking spray so nothing sticks and cleanup is a breeze.
- Throw Everything In
- Put your pasta, evaporated milk, whole milk, butter, salt and most of your hand-grated cheese straight in the pot. Stir it all gently and sprinkle the leftover cheese on top.
- Set It And Forget It
- Put the lid on and cook on low for 3 hours and 15 minutes. Don't lift the lid even if you want to, we need that steam inside.
- Serve It Up
- Give everything one last gentle mix to make sure the sauce coats everything, then dish it out while it's hot and gooey.
Insider Cooking Tricks
I've made this so many times and learned a few things. Always shred your cheese from a block because the bags of pre-shredded stuff won't melt right. Don't stir too much or you'll end up with soggy pasta. I usually sneak a peek around 2 hours just to check how the pasta's doing. And really try not to open that lid while cooking, the trapped steam is what makes everything come together.
Tasty Variations
I like to switch things up by adding smoky gouda or a bit of velveeta. My little ones go crazy when I top it with crunchy breadcrumbs. For a kick, we toss in some chopped jalapeños or a few drops of hot sauce. And when we want something extra rich, I'll swap in heavy cream instead of milk for an even more indulgent dish.
Great Side Matches
At our place, this mac and cheese works with just about anything. We love pairing it with some buttery garlic bread or a fresh green salad. It sits beautifully next to some BBQ chicken or shredded pork. Sometimes we just make this the main attraction with a simple veggie side. However you serve it, folks always want more.
FAQ Answers
People often ask why their mac turns mushy, and it's usually from cooking it too long or stirring it too much. If yours is grainy, you might've used packaged shredded cheese or your heat was too high. You can try any pasta shape you like, just watch your cooking time carefully. And nope, you don't need to boil the pasta first that's the whole point let your crockpot do the job for you.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Should I shred my own cheese?
Absolutely! Pre-shredded cheese has additives that stop smooth melting. Freshly shredded gives you a creamier, smoother dish.
- → Why just egg yolks, not whole eggs?
Yolks are less likely to curdle but still add a rich, creamy touch. Optional, but worth it for texture!
- → When is the mac ready?
Test pasta after 2 hours and stir. Slow cooker times vary, so keep checking—it should be soft, not mushy.
- → Can I scale this up?
Yep, but use a bigger cooker. Cooking time might shift, so watch closely when you double up.
- → Why mix milk types?
Evaporated milk gives richness and curdling protection, while whole milk adds the right consistency for the perfect cheese sauce.