Pin it
My kitchen gets all cozy when this smooth Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese starts bubbling in the oven. I've tweaked this dish for years until it hit perfection. There's something magical about how the butternut's sweet notes play with the rich Gruyère cheese in every spoonful. The minute fall arrives, my family starts asking for it non-stop, and honestly, I get why they can't wait.
Why This Dish Stands Out
We're not talking about regular mac and cheese here. Through many kitchen trials, I found that butternut squash adds this amazing velvety feel that's just next level. The nutty flavor from Gruyère really shines through, and I sneak kale in without anyone noticing they're getting vegetables. You'll soon be making this whenever you need something warm and tasty that feeds your soul.
Your Ingredient List
- 3 cups mashed potatoes when cold: Leftover spuds work great if they've been in the fridge. For new ones, let them cool all the way so they're easier to mix.
- 2 large eggs: They should be at room temp and beaten till they get foamy. They hold everything together and make the texture light.
- 1/4 cup chives, fresh: Cut them super small. If you've only got dried ones, just use 1 tablespoon. Green onions work too.
- 1 1/2 cups Monterey Jack cheese: Grate it yourself (1 cup goes in the mix, 1/2 cup on top). The bagged kind doesn't melt as nicely.
- 1 teaspoon salt: Go with fine sea salt or kosher to make flavors pop.
- 1/2 teaspoon black pepper: Grinding it fresh tastes way better.
- 1/2 cup sour cream: You don't have to use it, but it's great for serving. Full-fat gives the best feel.
Easy Steps to Follow
- Get Your Oven Ready
- Put your oven rack in the middle and turn it up to 400°F (200°C). Give a 24-cup mini muffin tin a good spray with non-stick stuff, making sure you get into all the little corners.
- Mix It All Up
- Grab a big bowl and stir your cold potatoes with the beaten eggs until they're just combined. Then add 1 cup cheese, the chopped chives, salt, and pepper. Mix it gently so everything's spread out, but don't overdo it.
- Get It In The Tin
- Use a small cookie scoop or a couple spoons to drop the mixture into each muffin cup (about 2 tablespoons per cup). They should be full but not spilling over. Smooth the tops with your spoon back. Sprinkle the leftover 1/2 cup cheese on all of them.
- Cook Them Just Right
- Bake for 15-20 minutes, and turn the pan around halfway. You want the tops golden and edges crispy. The cheese should be melted and a bit brown. Stick a knife in the middle - it should come out clean.
- Finish Them Off
- Take them out and let them sit in the pan for exactly 5 minutes so they can firm up. Carefully go around each one with a plastic knife, then take them out onto a plate. Add more chives if you want and serve them hot with sour cream on the side.
My Top Cooking Tips
Don't cut corners on the cheese, it really matters. Keep an eye on your pasta or you'll end up with mush. If you can't do nuts, try pepitas instead - they're awesome. Always give it a few minutes to sit before you dig in so the sauce gets thicker.
Ways to Switch It Up
Add some cooked chicken if you want more protein. Not into kale? Fresh spinach works just as well. My kids go nuts when I use smoky gouda instead of the usual cheese. For special times, throw some crispy bacon on top, or just pile on extra cheese if you want to keep it basic.
Fast Answers You Might Need
It tastes like creamy butternut with hints of nutty cheese and garlic. You can totally skip the greens or use something else. Leftovers go in the freezer for up to 3 months. If you're vegan, go with your favorite non-dairy cheese and use cashew cream instead of yogurt - it turns out great.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What makes squash a good addition to mac and cheese?
Squash adds a creamy, slightly sweet flavor and makes the sauce smoother. It also boosts the nutrition while cutting back on cheese.
- → Can this dish be prepped beforehand?
Yes, assemble and freeze before baking for up to 3 months or fully bake and freeze ready to reheat. Perfect for saving time later.
- → What's the purpose of Greek yogurt in the sauce?
It boosts protein and gives a slight tang to balance flavors. Use sour cream or cream cheese as swaps if needed.
- → Why is fresh cheese better than pre-shredded?
Fresh cheese melts more smoothly. Pre-grated often has additives that make sauces less creamy.
- → Do I have to use kale?
Not at all. Leave it out if it’s not your thing, or swap with spinach or broccoli for a little extra green.