Pin it
Nothing beats sinking your teeth into a hot, crisp Reuben sandwich. When tangy sauerkraut meets melt-in-your-mouth corned beef, gooey Swiss cheese, and rich thousand island dressing between two slices of toasty rye bread, you get a taste explosion that's been winning hearts ever since it first showed up in NYC.
Whenever I cook these sandwiches during family get-togethers, they're gone in seconds. Just the aroma of rye bread toasting in butter never fails to bring everyone running to the kitchen.
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice
- Dark Rye Bread: Go for hearty, new bread with seeds showing; it'll handle the heavy fillings better
- Corned Beef: Ask for fresh-cut at the deli, medium slices work great
- Sauerkraut: Pick the kind from the fridge section for better crunch and zip
- Swiss Cheese: Grate it yourself for smoother melting than the packaged stuff
- Thousand Island Dressing: Store-bought works fine, but homemade tastes amazing too
- Butter: Pick unsalted so you can control the salt level yourself
Step-By-Step Cooking Guide
- Step 1: Putting It Together
- - Use ingredients that aren't cold from the fridge
- Stack your sandwich this way: bread first, then cheese, dressing, corned beef, sauerkraut
- Push down lightly to keep everything together without crushing
- Spread butter smoothly on the outside of both bread pieces - Step 2: Grilling Done Right
- - Warm pan to medium heat (never crank it higher)
- Drop sandwich in with the buttered side down
- Use your spatula to apply gentle pressure for even browning
- Let it cook till it's gold-brown (roughly 3 minutes each side)
- Turn it over carefully so everything stays inside
When I was little, my grandma always piled extra sauerkraut on her Reubens. She'd talk about its tummy-friendly benefits and share tales of her mom fermenting cabbage in wooden casks at home.
Heat Level Is Crucial
Getting your Reuben just right depends on heat control. Cook too hot and you'll end up with burnt bread and half-melted cheese. Too low and you'll get a limp, soggy mess. I've learned that keeping it at medium lets the cheese melt perfectly while your bread turns that beautiful golden color.
Saving For Later and Prep Tips
Reubens taste best straight from the pan, but you can get things ready ahead of time. Keep all your stuff separate in the fridge, but don't forget to let the corned beef warm up to room temp before you build your sandwich. This tiny trick really makes your sandwich taste better.
Switch It Up Your Way
The standard Reuben can't be beat, but feel free to tweak it. Swap in pastrami for a smoky twist, or try adding different mustards with your thousand island dressing. Some folks tell me they love using turkey for a lighter sandwich, though die-hard fans might say that's not really a Reuben anymore.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What bread should I use for a great Reuben?
- Go with rye bread, either dark or light. It’s firm and matches the fillings perfectly.
- → Is pastrami an OK swap for corned beef?
- Totally! Pastrami works wonderfully and adds a great twist to the sandwich.
- → How do I stop the bread from getting soggy?
- Squeeze out all the liquid from your sauerkraut before layering and toast the bread well.
- → What’s the go-to cheese for this sandwich?
- Swiss cheese melts beautifully and has the best creamy, mild taste for the job.
- → Can I prep this sandwich in advance?
- For best results, assemble and toast fresh, but keep the ingredients ready to go if needed.