Pin it
Cooking turkey doesn't have to be tricky. Forget about brining or basting. You'll end up with juicy meat and crispy skin with hardly any hassle. Just use an easy herb butter, keep the oven at the right temperature, and you're set for a perfect bird weighing between 12 to 18 pounds. No matter your cooking skills, you can pull this off.
Why You'll Love This
Making turkey is easier when you stick to simplicity. Herb butter keeps things juicy and you can skip the mess of basting. Instead of guessing, you just check the temperature. All you need is a roasting rack, meat thermometer, and a decent knife. The steps aren’t fussy and they always do the trick, no matter if you’re feeding two or a whole crew.
Gather Up These Items
- Turkey: Use one thawed turkey (12-18 lbs), let it get to room temp
- Butter rub: ¾ cup soft butter, 6 garlic cloves smashed up, one hefty spoon each chopped rosemary and thyme
- Seasonings: Big pinch kosher salt and black pepper for butter and inside the bird
- What goes inside: 1 peeled onion (quarter it), 1 lemon (quarter that too), 2 sprigs each rosemary, thyme, and sage
- Veggie extras (optional): 1 onion cut up, 3 celery stalks chopped, 2 carrots diced for roasting in the pan
Simple Instructions
- Final Touches
- Let the turkey rest for half an hour before you cut it up. Check that the internal temp hits 165°F before slicing. Serve it warm and enjoy.
- Oven Time
- Rest your bird on a roasting rack or a pile of veggies. Cook for about 15 minutes per pound. Check it's 160°F in the thickest spot. If the outside skin looks like it's browning too quickly, lay some foil over the bird loosely.
- Lather It Up
- Slip your fingers gently under the skin so you can slather a third of your butter mixture underneath. Rub the rest all around the outside. Try not to miss any spots.
- Mix, Season, Prep
- Sprinkle salt and pepper inside the turkey. Stuff in the onion, lemon, and herbs. Blend garlic, soft butter, herbs, salt, and pepper together.
- Start Off Right
- Give your turkey an hour out of the fridge before it hits the oven. Get your oven hot at 325°F. Pull out giblets and use paper towels to pat everything dry.
Thawing Tips
Thawing takes a while, so don't leave it to the last minute. Keep your bird in the fridge—let it hang out for a day for every five pounds. That means you’ll want a solid three days for a 15-pounder. Pop it on a tray on the fridge’s bottom shelf just in case it drips. Never let it sit on the counter - that’s how folks get sick. If you need to speed things up, use cold water and swap it out every half hour.
Pin it
No Need To Wash
Don't bother washing the turkey - it's not helpful and just splashes germs everywhere. The heat in the oven does the trick for bacteria. Just grab some paper towels and dry the bird off well. This turns the skin nice and crispy, plus keeps cleaning easy. Use separate boards for meat and veggies, and always wash hands after touching raw turkey.
Stuffing On The Side
Bake your stuffing in a dish instead of shoving it in the turkey. Filling the cavity with stuffing makes everything cook slower and you might get soggy bread. Drop herbs, onions, and lemon inside the turkey just for taste. This way, your turkey cooks evenly and the stuffing gets a crunchy, golden top every time.
How To Get That Crispy Outside
Want crisp, golden skin? Let your turkey dry out uncovered in the fridge for a few hours or overnight after patting it dry. Smear on the herb butter (get under and over the skin) right before you start cooking. Leave the oven shut - too many peeks make it take longer. Basting isn't needed because the butter's already doing its magic for perfect crispy skin.
Pin it
Rest Before You Carve
Give your turkey a good rest—shoot for at least 30 minutes, or up to an hour if it’s a big one. Slicing early means all those tasty juices leak out and you end up with dry slices. Tent with foil to keep things cozy. That’s the perfect time to whip up gravy, reheat your sides, or round folks up for dinner. Being patient here means juicier turkey for everyone.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make herb butter ahead?
You can whip it up two days before, just soften before using. Wrap tight and chill. Freeze it for weeks—just let it sit out a bit before spreading. If you want fresh zest, add that last minute for the best pop.
- → No fresh herbs - now what?
Go for dried ones—about a third the amount of fresh. Mix them right in. Dried herbs pack more punch, so start with a small bit. Rosemary and thyme hold up great, basil not as much. Fresh is best, but dried gets the job done.
- → How do I know it's done?
Pop a thermometer in the thickest thigh, aim for 158-160°. Skip the bone so you don't get wonky numbers. Test a couple spots just to be sure. Color can fool you—go by temp. White cooks quicker, so test both. Let it rest to hit 165° and keep it juicy.
- → Should I stuff the bird?
Safer and easier to bake stuffing on the side. The turkey bakes up better empty, plus it’s faster. Pop some onion, lemon, and herbs inside for flavor. Stuffing in a pan gets a crispy top too! Some folks just toss in citrus and herbs for the smell.
- → How long to rest it?
Let it sit at least 30 but 45 minutes is even better. Foil it lightly to stay warm, not soggy. Time to whip up gravy or set the table. Cutting too soon? You'll lose those tasty juices! Resting really helps keep it moist.
Conclusion
Like quick meals? Try out herb roasted chicken or toss together lemony roasted veggies for a fresh side. Garlic mashed potatoes using these herbs taste just as cozy!