Pin it
Picture cheesy, baked macaroni loaded with creamy sauce, tender noodles, and a top layer that goes crispy in all the right ways. It’s the kind of dish that feels like a big warm hug. With easy steps and down-to-earth stuff, you’ll have it on the table for a weeknight or a holiday get-together in about an hour.
Top Reasons to Try This
You get real, melty cheese—no fake powders, no weird flavors—plus a sauce that turns out smooth every time. The crunchy topping is the perfect finishing touch after some oven time, and it’s kind on your wallet since most of it’s stuff you already have. This one even works great if you wanna prep ahead, either for a crowd or just a busy evening.
What You'll Need
- Cheese: 5 cups sharp cheddar, shredded and split for sauce and topping
- Milk: 3 cups (whole milk, warmed up)
- Butter: 1/2 cup (unsalted, used for both sauce and pasta)
- Pasta: 1 pound elbow macaroni or a similar short noodle
- Flour: 1/4 cup, to help thicken the sauce up
- Seasonings: 1 tsp pepper, 1 tsp salt, 1/2 tsp paprika
- Hot Sauce: Just a few drops if you like (totally optional)
How to Make It
- Bake It All Together
- Spoon everything into your baking dish and cover the top with that last bit of cheese. Bake for around 25 to 30 minutes until you see bubbles and a golden crust.
- Mix Cheese Into Sauce
- Stir 4 cups of the shredded cheese and the seasonings into your sauce mix. Keep stirring until everything melts and gets nice and smooth. Drop in the noodles and combine.
- Begin Your Sauce
- In a big pot, melt the rest of your butter. Add your flour, cooking and stirring for about 2 or 3 minutes until you see a light, toasty color. Slowly pour in the warm milk as you whisk, so it comes out lump-free.
- Boil the Noodles
- Toss your macaroni in boiling water until soft but still a little firm—about 8 minutes. Drain them off, stir in a spoonful of butter, and set your oven to 375°F.
Pin it
What Sets This Apart
This dish wins folks over with the basics: real cheese, super creamy texture, and that perfect, golden, cheesy top. Skip the fancy extras—this is straightforward comfort food, loved by kids and adults. The creaminess stays put, noodles don't turn mushy, and everyone fights for the edges with all that crispy cheese.
Cheese Sauce Success Tips
Want lump-free, creamy sauce? Keep your stove at medium-low and don't let the cheese sauce heat up too quickly. Pour in the milk bit by bit as you whisk. Grated-from-block cheese melts smoother than the bagged stuff. Let your cheese sit out so it’s not cold when tossed in. If the sauce seems gritty, splash in a bit more warm milk and stir it gently to fix it.
Ways to Make it Yours
After nailing the basics, make things interesting with your own twists. Swap in cheeses—sharp cheddar plus some Monterey Jack is awesome. Try throwing bacon bits or diced jalapeños right into the mix. Amp up the spice with extra hot sauce or swap in pepper jack. For more crunch on top, scatter breadcrumbs before baking. Just stick to the same pasta and sauce ratios for best results.
How to Serve It
Scoop out your mac and cheese while it’s still hot, either as the star with a side salad or sitting next to something like ham or meatloaf. It fits in at big Sunday lunches or buffet tables just as well. Need more? Double the batch and grab a bigger baking dish; just tack on another 5 to 10 minutes of baking.
Storing and Warming Up
Leftovers? Just cover and stash them in your fridge for up to 4 days. When it’s time to reheat, add a splash of milk and warm up slowly—microwave or oven is fine. Stir once in a while for best results. Warm up small batches for extra creaminess. Sometimes the noodles drink up some sauce in the fridge, so that milk really helps out.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use different cheese?
Try Gouda for extra smoothness, Jack for mellow taste, or sharp cheddar for more bite. Mixing is the real win—lots of people go half cheddar, half Gouda. Don't pick up bagged shredded stuff, it won’t melt right. Freshly grated always melts better.
- → Need it gluten-free?
Swap for gluten-free pasta and a flour blend. Rice noodles work well, just don’t cook them as long as the box says. Watch out for cheese with hidden starch. Might soak up more liquid, so toss in a splash extra. Gluten-free can take a bit to thicken up—some folks add more cheese to fix texture.
- → Can I make it ahead?
Stir everything together the night before and refrigerate. Take out half an hour before baking. Since it'll be cold, let it cook a little longer. Another idea: make two pans, freeze one for later. Splash in a little milk while reheating if it's thick. Save adding topping till right before baking.
- → What makes it better?
Add crunchy bacon on top or toast bread crumbs with butter for a golden, crispy layer. Some toss on jalapeños for heat, or sweet onions for flavor. Whatever you pick, set it on before it hits the oven so it bakes in with the cheese.
- → How do I warm leftovers?
Pop in the oven and add a dash of milk, covered with foil so it won’t dry out. In the microwave, go slow and stir now and then, plus extra milk as you go. Quick broil at the end gets the top crisp again.
Conclusion
If you love gooey cheese, toss together some garlic cheese bread or throw together a broccoli cheese bake next time you want something cozy.