Pin it
Turn basic veggies into a fancy sandwich treat with stacked pickled onions, smooth spreads, and garden-fresh produce. This sandwich brings out the real taste of each item, making a perfect mix of soft and crunchy bits that'll make you want more with every bite.
I came up with this mix when trying to copy a sandwich from the café down the street. After playing around a bunch, this version is even better than what I was trying to match, and now we can't go a week without it.
Picking Your Ingredients:
- Sourdough bread: Get the good stuff with a firm outside and soft, stretchy inside
- Cream cheese: Use the real deal, not low-fat, and let it sit out to soften
- Greek yogurt: You can put it in a cloth to drain if it's too runny
- Fresh herbs: Look for vibrant ones with no dark edges
- Tomatoes: Go for colorful ones that aren't too soft when squeezed
- Avocados: They should give just a little when you press them
- English cucumber: The skinny kind you don't need to peel
- Red onions: Pick ones that feel heavy and don't have loose layers
- Sprouts: Make sure they're dry and perky looking
How To Make It:
- Making Pink Onions:
- Cut red onion into super thin rings. Throw them in a bowl with lime juice from one lime, add some salt and pepper. Let them hang out for half an hour, giving them a stir now and then. They'll get soft and turn a pretty pink color.
- Whipping Up Herby Cheese:
- Beat the soft cream cheese until it's all fluffy. Slowly mix in your Greek yogurt till it's smooth as can be. Toss in salt, pepper, onion powder and chopped fresh herbs. Let it sit for 30 minutes so the flavors can get friendly.
- Getting Bread Ready:
- Turn your broiler on high. Spread butter all over one side of each bread slice. Put them butter-side up on a baking sheet. Broil until they're golden on top but still got some give when you press them.
- Prepping Tomatoes:
- Cut tomatoes into medium-thick slices. Lay them on paper towels and sprinkle both sides with plenty of salt and pepper. Let them sit and drain for 10 minutes each side. Pat them dry before using.
- Mashing Avocados:
- Scoop avocados into a bowl and squash them up however chunky or smooth you want. Right away, mix in lemon juice and salt to keep them green. For super smooth results, throw it all in a food processor.
- Putting It All Together:
- Lay your toast pieces with the toasty sides facing up. Spread one piece with your herb cheese mix and the other with avocado. Stack tomatoes, cucumber, and those pink onions on the cheese side. Add some cheese if you want. Top with a big handful of sprouts and spinach. Put the two halves together and press down lightly.
Pin it
Every bit matters here. The pink onions bring zing, the two spreads add richness, and the fresh veggies give you that satisfying crunch.
Do-Ahead Tricks:
Fix those pink onions up to a week early. Mix your herb spread three days before. Slice all your veggies the morning you'll eat.
Keeping It Fresh:
Store everything in different containers. Put plastic wrap right on top of the avocado mix to stop it turning brown.
What Goes With It:
Try it with a hot soup when it's cold out or a crisp salad in summer. Cold cucumber soup works great any time of year.
Pin it
This sandwich turns plain veggies into something special. The mix of tangy pink onions, creamy spreads, and crunchy fresh vegetables creates so many flavor layers that even meat-lovers won't miss a thing.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prepare the herb spread in advance?
- Definitely! It’ll keep well in the fridge for up to 5 days.
- → What’s the trick to avoid soggy bread?
- Spread the condiments on the toasted sides and keep wet ingredients like tomatoes on top of the spread.
- → Do I have to use sourdough bread?
- Not at all! Any solid, toastable bread works fine.
- → How long can I store pickled onions?
- They stay good in the fridge for up to a week.
- → Is this sandwich vegan-friendly?
- It can be! Use dairy-free cream cheese and skip the Havarti cheese.