Pin it
Sunday Pot Roast Sauce has turned into a family favorite at my house. There's something magical about how the soft pot roast blends with the deep tomato sauce, mixing perfectly with those spicy sausage bits and al dente rigatoni. Whenever I cook it, wonderful smells fill our home and everyone rushes to grab a seat at the table.
What Makes This Stand Out
I'm always amazed how this dish turns basic pot roast into something so fancy. The long cooking time makes it taste incredibly rich while still being easy on the wallet. It's my number one pick when I've got many mouths to feed, and the best part? The extras taste even better the next day.
Everything You Need
- Chuck Roast: This cut gets super tender and packs tons of flavor.
- Italian Sausage: I shape these into small bite-sized meatballs.
- Fresh Vegetables: They build the foundation of taste.
- Herbs: Both dried and fresh add wonderful scents.
- Good Tomatoes: I find San Marzano really ups the game.
- Tomato Paste: Adds that concentrated flavor kick.
- Red Wine: Brings extra layers of taste.
- Rigatoni: These hollow tubes grab all the sauce goodness.
- Finishing Touches: Cream, butter and parmesan make everything so smooth.
Let's Start Cooking
- Setting Up
- First thing I do is season those chunky beef pieces and put them in my Dutch oven with the tiny sausage balls I've rolled.
- Building Layers
- Next come all the vegetables and herbs, and wow, they smell amazing before cooking even starts.
- Time for Magic
- After four hours of slow cooking, everything turns into this incredible sauce. Sometimes I make it a night before since it tastes even better the next day.
- Bringing it Together
- While the pasta boils, I pull apart that soft pot roast and mix it back into the sauce.
- Final Touch
- Mixing in cream, butter and parmesan at the end makes everything come together beautifully.
Pin it
Planning Ahead
What I really love is how much this sauce makes. We'll have it for dinner, then I pack away the rest in containers for the fridge or freezer. It's like leaving a gift for my busy future self - just heat and eat for a fast comfort meal anytime.
Perfect Partners
This sauce goes great with a simple winter salad, as the fresh greens really balance out the richness. And don't forget some crusty bread too - everyone always wants to mop up every bit of that amazing sauce from their plates.
Kitchen Essentials
My Dutch oven does the heavy lifting here, cooking everything so evenly and slowly. When life gets crazy, I'll switch to my slow cooker and let it do all the work. Both ways turn out super tasty results that never disappoint.
New Takes on Tradition
This isn't exactly what my Italian grandma would make, but using pot roast brings its own kind of special. I love how it creates such a fancy sauce without breaking the bank. The meat just falls apart and blends into every bite, making everything taste so rich.
Why I Love Pot Roast
Pot roast has become my go-to meat for this sauce. It changes completely during that long cooking time, creating soft strands that soak up all the flavors. It costs way less than short ribs but the results are still totally amazing.
Little Touches of Magic
I'll sometimes toss in a tiny star anise for extra warmth. A good pour of red wine adds depth and fresh herbs make everything smell so good. When you finish with that swirl of cream and sprinkle of parmesan, the sauce turns silky smooth.
Any Day is Sunday
We call it Sunday sauce but honestly it works for any day you want something comforting. From casual family dinners to holiday get-togethers or friend gatherings, it always gets compliments. I love that I can make it ahead which makes hosting so much easier.
Creating Memories
This sauce means more than just food in our home. It brings everyone together, creating those special moments where we talk and laugh over good wine. Every time I cook it, I'm reminded why sharing meals with people we care about matters so much.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Will this work in a slow cooker?
- Definitely. Just cook it on low for 8-10 hours until the meat falls apart. Then move to your stovetop for mixing in pasta and cream at the end.
- → What's the point of star anise?
- Star anise brings a hidden layer of flavor to meat dishes. You can skip it if you want, but many Italian-American families use it as their secret touch.
- → Can I cook this beforehand?
- You can make the sauce up to 3 days early and warm it later. Just wait to add the cream and butter when you're mixing with fresh pasta.
- → What's a good swap for wine?
- If you don't have wine, try using more beef broth with 2 tablespoons of balsamic vinegar mixed in.
- → Are San Marzano tomatoes really worth it?
- San Marzano tomatoes taste sweeter with less acid than regular ones, making your sauce way better. Regular crushed tomatoes work too if that's all you've got.