Pin it
This Sugar Cookie Cheesecake feels like a holiday in every bite. There's a sweet sugar cookie layer at the bottom, then a fluffy cheesecake packed with little bits of cookie dough, and it's all finished off with melty white chocolate. Great for any celebration, or whenever you need to impress with something that looks tough but is easy to throw together.
Top Reasons to Try
If you can't pick between cheesecake and sugar cookies, this one's got you covered. It's a real crowd-pleaser and everyone will want to know how you did it. Grab the best sugar you can; it really does make a big difference. Those hidden cookie dough balls turn plain cheesecake into something extra fun.
Things to Grab
- 9-inch Pan: The kind that snaps open
- Sprinkles: Pick festive ones for your vibe
- White Chocolate: Use for the final layer
- Heavy Cream: Needed for mixing and pouring on top
- Sour Cream: Keeps it creamy
- Cream Cheese: You need four blocks
- Eggs: Go with large ones
- Vanilla: Real is the way to go
- Sugar: White, standard stuff
- Butter: Unsalted is best and plenty of it
- Salt: Just a pinch
- Baking Soda: Use a small amount
- Flour: Classic, all-purpose for baking
Steps to Pull It Off
- Make the finishing touch:
- Warm heavy cream and pour over white chocolate. Stir until even and glossy. Spread over cold cake and toss on leftover cookie balls and plenty of sprinkles.
- Chill it out:
- Let cake sit in an oven with the door cracked thirty minutes, then move out to cool more. Pop it in the fridge and forget about it until tomorrow.
- Put it all together:
- Pour cheesecake mixture over the cookie base once it's cool. Put that pan inside a bigger, water-filled pan. Bake about an hour and a half, just until the middle wobbles a little.
- Mix cheesecake filling:
- Drop oven heat to 325. Whip cream cheese and sugar til totally smooth, no lumps at all. Blend in sour cream, vanilla, cream, then slowly add eggs. Gently fold frozen dough balls into the mix.
- Create dough balls:
- Whip up another cookie dough batch with flour, salt, sugar, butter, vanilla, plus a splash of milk. Roll lots of tiny balls and freeze them hard.
- Form the cookie base:
- Stir baking soda, salt, flour together. In a different bowl, beat butter and sugar till really light, then crack in eggs, add vanilla, mix in dry stuff. Press into your pan and bake 25 minutes until deeper golden.
- Prep your pan:
- Heat oven to 350. Grease that springform pan and line the bottom with some baking paper.
Pin it
The Scoop on Sugar
Top-quality sugar makes everything taste brighter. Get the nicest you can find, but good old white works too. The big trick is to cream it really well with soft butter. That step brings out the best flavor.
Dough Ball Magic
Keep those dough balls teeny, like a penny in size. Kids have a blast rolling them. Freeze so they don't melt in your mix. If eating raw dough isn't your thing, just use ready cookie dough from the store.
Nail That Cheesecake
Let the cream cheese rest out and soften so you don't get lumps. Don't overmix the eggs or you could get cracks. The water pan helps keep everything smooth and dreamy. Leave the oven open after to cool—no splits that way. Takes patience but it's so worth it.
White Chocolate Finish
Chop up the chocolate tiny so it melts easy. If you get the cream too warm, the chocolate's texture goes weird. Work fast to spread it on before it firms up. Swirls make a fun look if you're into that. Chill the cake before slicing pieces.
Storing and Freezing
It'll be fresh for five days in your fridge if you cover it well so it won't get dry. For neat slices, use a hot knife and wipe it clean each time. If you want to keep it longer, wrap pieces tight and freeze for a month. Let them thaw a bit before you dig in.
Change It Up
Swap sprinkle colors for whatever you're celebrating. Toss chocolate chips in the batter if you want more chocolatey bites. Want it extra fancy? Add swirls of whipped cream on top. Or make mini cheesecakes using a muffin pan, just bake them for less time.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make this early?
This actually turns out even better if you prep it ahead of time! Make it a day before so everything chills and settles well. Texture gets smoother after hanging out overnight in the fridge. Thinking ahead? Bake Thursday, slice it up on Saturday. Just wrap it tight so it doesn't grab funky fridge smells. Most folks say it’s tastiest two or three days later. Takes a little planning, but you'll find serving super smooth.
- → No sour cream - what else works?
Greek yogurt totally saves the day! Swap in the same amount as sour cream. It'll taste a bit tangier, still creamy. Plain yogurt works but too watery—let it drip in a strainer first. If you want, blend some cream cheese with milk for a richer bite. Heavy cream is a good fix, too. Just be sure everything’s room temp before mixing or you’ll have lumpy batter. Don't use runny yogurt, though—it ruins the texture!
- → How do I get it to set right?
You need a water bath, that keeps your cake nice and even—no cracks. Set your wrapped springform into a bigger pan, fill with hot water halfway up the sides. Don’t forget to pull that foil around tight so water can’t sneak in. Keep the oven door shut while it’s baking. When it’s done, let it cool with the oven off and door slightly open. Middle should jiggle a little; if it's too wobbly, just give it five more minutes.
- → Store-bought dough okay?
Totally! It makes life easier. Just grab some sugar cookie dough from the store, let it soften so you can press it in quick. Break it apart first—it spreads better. Some brands are firmer than others, so pick one that's not mushy. Get your hands a little damp so it won’t stick. Sprinkle sugar on before baking if you want extra sparkle. Nobody’s gonna guess it came from a package!
- → How do I store extras?
Just keep it in the fridge! Use a snug container—good for about five days. Wrap single slices or they’ll get dry. Don’t freeze the whole thing—the texture gets weird. But wrapped slices can go in the freezer, just thaw them in the fridge overnight. Pull slices out half an hour before eating so they get creamy. For a summer treat, try them just barely thawed—like a cheesecake popsicle!
Conclusion
Like this idea? Try making bite-size cheesecake pops with cookie crumbs. Or toss everything in a jar—instant dessert. Same awesome flavors, just switch up how it looks!